Moms Of Boys Speak Out – Are They Jealous Of Friends With Daughters?

by Life Without Pink on June 25, 2012

I often get asked, “Are you going to try for a girl?” or “Do you get jealous of other moms with daughters?”

Here’s the thing.

Did I want a daughter? Yes, of course.

Do I feel like my life is missing something without one? Absolutely not.

When my husband and I got married, we decided two kids would be the perfect amount for our family.

I always imagined that I would have a son and daughter.

Six years later, I’m a mom of all boys.

I used to get that feeling like I was punched in the stomach when I thought about the fact that I’d never have a daughter.

I was never jealous of my friends, I just felt sad and sorry for myself.

I have a very close relationship with my mom. We talk every day and only live 10 minutes from each other.

My mother is my best friend and I wish I had a daughter for that very reason.

But there is a special bond between a mother and her son.

My only hope is that I continue to have a strong relationship with my boys and that we will always remain close.

I truly believe I was meant to be a “boy-mom”.

Now, after having two boys, I never think about having a daughter.

I love my life and focus on how lucky I am to have two sweet, healthy and loveable boys.

My husband said to me a long time ago that as the boys grow up, I could either choose to sit back and watch or I could be part of their adventures.

At that moment, I decided I would be right there beside them no matter what.

I might not always enjoy it, like fishing or watching football, but I won’t let these memories pass me by.

I want them to know that I’ll be there every step of the way to hold their hand when they need one, guide them when they need help, to show them how to be silly and enjoy life and lend my shoulder when they need someone to lean on.

So, am I jealous of my friends with daughters? Definitely not.

I think there is something very special about being a mom of all boys, and I would never change my life.

 

I asked other fellow “boy-Moms” what their thoughts were. Do they get jealous of friends that have daughters? Do they feel like they are missing out?

Hilliary from my scraps:  I don’t get jealous. . .but sometimes (like when a new Lands End catalog comes) I wish I had a girl to buy girlie clothes for. I love my boys and wouldn’t trade being a boy-mom for anything. But they do make incredibly adorable things for little girls!

Sharon from Sharon Blog: I have two boys ages 9 and 10 and have to honestly say I am jealous some of the time. I do think that boys are easier but I would love to dress up a girl.

Jessica from Found the Marbles: I don’t get jealous now (because I was so meant to be a boy mom). Yet I worry a lot whether my boys will still want to spend time with me when they are adults. Does that make sense? My only other friend from college that has two boys is very envious of her friends with girls. She wanted a girl more than anything.

Andrea from Lil-Kid-Things: We were convinced that our first was a girl. When I found out he was a boy I cried because I felt like I lost my girl even though I never had her. With our second, I was convinced it was a girl because the pregnancy was SO different and I was SO relieved when we found out Calvin was a boy. We are done having kids, but I am terrified of a surprise pregnancy and the possibility of it being a girl. I can honestly say that I have NO desire to raise a girl of my own at this point.

Jessica from The B Keeps Us Honest {ages 4 & 1 and due in Oct}: I am pregnant with baby boy #3. While I don’t think I’m jealous of people that have girls and I am a little sad that I don’t have a daughter. We’ve talked about being “done” but honestly after I found out baby 3 was a boy I secretly wanted to have another in hopes it could be a girl. I don’t think it’s fair to keeping having kids in hopes that it will be a certain sex but still part of me wonders. I think what saddens me most is that I won’t have a mother/daughter relationship like my mom and I have. But with all that said, I always wanted to be the mom of boys and I wouldn’t trade it for the world.

Stephanie from  The Daily Blarg: I have 2 boys that are 16 and 14. I admit it, I’m envious of those with little girls. I always felt like I was meant to have a daughter and when my husband pulled the plug on more kids the feeling didn’t disappear.   I have found spending time with and spoiling my little nieces helps fill the void. I love buying them clothes and dolls and playing dress up with them.  But, the reality is I have all boys. I try to focus on the joy they bring versus the unknown joy I could possibly have with a little girl.

Mychal from My Life In Mommyland:  I TOTALLY feel that way. I refuse to actually come out and say I’m done because I feel like my life isn’t going to be complete without a little girl. I feel like I’m missing out on part of life being a mom of just boys. I look at the relationship I have with my mom and I want that too someday and daughter in law isn’t the same as daughter. Don’t get me wrong, I wouldn’t trade my boys in for anything but I feel like something may be missing.

Debbie from Mamanista: I have two boys, but I hope to have a third child eventually. I’d be delighted it I had a girl. I’ve dreamed of doing girly things with a daughter for a long time. I’m not embarrassed to admit that, but I also know that I would love another boy every bit as much as a girl. While I’m sometimes jealous of friends with girls when I hear about their spa days and shopping trips, I love being a mom to boys. It also helps to know that some of my friends with girls have admitted that they hope to have a boy eventually.

Nichole from Nicole Ann:  I am thrilled to have my son and love him to bits, but I will always be a little envious of mothers with daughters. While TTC, I secretly hoped for twins, not for the cuteness factor, but because I knew we likely wouldn’t try for a second child. One baby exhausted me so I can only imagine what boy/girl twins would have been like! But had the fantasy come true, it would have fulfilled my desire for both a daughter and a second child.

Diane from Knitting Zeal: Honestly, I was sad when I found out during pregnancy that my one and only was a boy. All I could think about was no American girl dolls in my future and no Lilly Pulitzer pink and green bedroom! So silly! Now I can’t believe I had those thoughts as my little guy is wonderful. I do have to admit that at Easter time, all those little girls Spring dresses gets me still. And the tutus. If I had a girl, there would be lots of tutus in my house! Instead, we have tons of trains and cars. It’s a lot of fun!

Trina from O’Boy Organic: I always wanted a 3rd child but after having 2 boys I honestly don’t care if the 3rd was a girl. I am so jealous of all the cute clothes and I am sad that I will never have that mother daughter relationship as I do with my own mother. I hope my daughter in laws are amazing!

You shouldn’t feel embarrassed or ashamed for wishing you had a daughter. It doesn’t mean you love your son{s} any less, it just means you are human.

I’d love to hear from you!

Meet Life Without Pink


I'm Tina, a wife and mother of two very active little boys. I'm the Co-founder of Girls' Lunch Out {GLO}, a marketing company that hosts networking events for women in social media. I'm also part of the BabyCenter social media team and the Family Expert for P&G's Have You Tried This Yet? Trend Trio.

Related Posts with Thumbnails
If you liked this post, please consider leaving a comment or Subscribe to the RSS feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader. Thank you!

{ 39 comments… read them below or add one }

1 Melissa Chapman June 25, 2012 at 9:40 am

TINA– I.LOVE.THIS.POST!!!!! The honesty, the bravery and the fact that you LOVE being a BOY-MOM… those kidlets of yours are BEYOND lucky!!!
Melissa Chapman´s last [type] ..Should parents force their kids to be “nice” ?

Reply

2 Tina @ Life Without Pink June 26, 2012 at 10:53 am

Thank you so much Melissa, means so much!
Tina @ Life Without Pink´s last [type] ..Moms Of Boys Speak Out – Are They Jealous Of Friends With Daughters?

Reply

3 Glamamom June 25, 2012 at 9:50 am

I’m not ashamed to admit I’m disappointed I don’t have a girl. It doesn’t mean I love my son and baby on the way any less, just that I would like/would have liked to have a girl. The relationship between a mother and daughter is of course different and girls, well, they tend to be more complicated and some of us like complicated! But I would not trade my family and the dynamic we have for anything and believe I was given what I’m supposed to have. I love all the comments about the clothes/dress-up. Definitely an issue for me but my book is written yet so we’ll see :) Fun post, Tina.
Glamamom´s last [type] ..Ghost | The Musical

Reply

4 Tina @ Life Without Pink June 26, 2012 at 10:56 am

Yes, but think about how fashionable your boys will be! I need to take some lessons from you :)
Tina @ Life Without Pink´s last [type] ..Moms Of Boys Speak Out – Are They Jealous Of Friends With Daughters?

Reply

5 Barbara June 25, 2012 at 9:52 am

I would have loved having a girl, and since we are hoping to add one more to our family I hope that it will be a girl. I love being a boy mom though, and I love the bond that I have with my boys. My husband on the other hand definitely feels a void, he’s always dreamed of having “daddy’s little girl”.
Barbara´s last [type] ..Dear Nathan….

Reply

6 Tina @ Life Without Pink June 26, 2012 at 10:57 am

Aw! Yes I always wonder how my hubby would be with a girl…he was a little scared to have one – thinking he’d be too overprotective.
Tina @ Life Without Pink´s last [type] ..Moms Of Boys Speak Out – Are They Jealous Of Friends With Daughters?

Reply

7 Charmin @ the Momiverse June 25, 2012 at 9:54 am

Well said, Tina! As a mom of boys, I feel exactly the same as you. I always thought I wanted a boy & girl. Because I’m close to my mom, I wanted the same sort of relationship with my own daughter.

I love being a mom of boys! I couldn’t imagine life any other way. And a kinda like being the only girl in my house! ;-)
Charmin @ the Momiverse´s last [type] ..7 tips for helping a child who is terrified of the pool

Reply

8 Tina @ Life Without Pink June 26, 2012 at 10:57 am

I feel the same way as you Charmin…told you we are too much alike! XOXO
Tina @ Life Without Pink´s last [type] ..Moms Of Boys Speak Out – Are They Jealous Of Friends With Daughters?

Reply

9 JDaniel4's Mom June 25, 2012 at 10:14 am

I love being a boy mom! I wanted to a boy to name after my husband and his dad, but it turned out to be the perfect child for me to bother. Dirt and trucks are so much fun!
JDaniel4′s Mom´s last [type] ..Muffin Tin Monday- Friendship and the 4th of July

Reply

10 Tina @ Life Without Pink June 26, 2012 at 10:58 am

Yes they are…and I’ve learned so much about Super Heroes!
Tina @ Life Without Pink´s last [type] ..Moms Of Boys Speak Out – Are They Jealous Of Friends With Daughters?

Reply

11 Kelly @LifeOptimist June 25, 2012 at 10:29 am

I’ve always wanted a boy, so I’m glad that I have my son. I find girls too whiny (and they scream!) and they tend to be mischievous when they get into trouble. Boys, by contrast, just get dirty and I’m totally fine with that. I have two nieces I can buy cute clothes for and I don’t mind doing that, but I much prefer how much easier it is to shop for a boy and how much more fun they are to play with. I would go crazy if I had to be around a whiny little girl all the time.
Kelly @LifeOptimist´s last [type] ..Different is Not Wrong

Reply

12 Tina @ Life Without Pink June 26, 2012 at 11:13 am

Haha…yeah boys are filled with lots of energy that’s for sure!
Tina @ Life Without Pink´s last [type] ..Moms Of Boys Speak Out – Are They Jealous Of Friends With Daughters?

Reply

13 Danielle September 8, 2012 at 9:19 am

Did not like your comment at all. Boys can be just as whiny as girls, if not even more whiny. My 3rd boy is the whiniest in my house! My girls is no drama at all. I have 3 awesome boys and I desperately wanted a girl (I got my little sweet girl – she’s my youngest and is 10 now).

Reply

14 Rachel @ The House of Burks June 25, 2012 at 11:05 am

I LOVE being a boy mom! I honestly have no desire to have a daughter. I think I’m missing a chip or something, haha. We were so happy to find out we were having a boy first, and then overjoyed (and a little relieved) when we found out that our second child was a boy. I know how girls are, and I know how hard the school years can be for girls. I went through it myself. If sparing a child of mine the pain that I saw some of my friends go through as a high school girl means that I have all boys, then I am a-okay with it.

My husband and I would like another child in a few years, and we would be happy with a healthy baby of either sex. But we are having the time of our lives as parents of two amazing little boys, and part of us would be hoping for a third boy!
Rachel @ The House of Burks´s last [type] ..Can I get a do-over?

Reply

15 Tina @ Life Without Pink June 28, 2012 at 8:29 pm

Yes, I know it’s so hard being a girl in high school…if I had a daughter I’d be a nervous-wreck!
Tina @ Life Without Pink´s last [type] ..How To Carve A T-Rex Watermelon

Reply

16 Melissa June 25, 2012 at 4:13 pm

Each time we found out we were having a boy I was a little disappointed but it didn’t dampen my excitement about a new baby. After my third pregnancy the Dr. recommended no more pregnancies and so I had a tubal. When my youngest was around a year old there was a time that I grieved for the little girl I never had. My youngest is now seven and I am very happy with my family. I enjoy being a boy mom and my husband says that is what I was meant to be. I am not a girly girl and I enjoy fishing, hunting and sports so it works. :)

Reply

17 Tina @ Life Without Pink June 28, 2012 at 8:30 pm

I am a lot like you. I was never a girly girl either and I am actually enjoying doing all the “boy” stuff. I think I was meant to be a mom to all boys too…the only life I know :)
Tina @ Life Without Pink´s last [type] ..How To Carve A T-Rex Watermelon

Reply

18 Kristen @ The Preppy Girl in Pink June 25, 2012 at 5:11 pm

I have two girls and I always wanted a boy so I “borrow” my nephew and my close friend’s son when I need some boy time. It is a win-win. I get to hang out with two cool little boys and their moms get a break.
Kristen @ The Preppy Girl in Pink´s last [type] ..Tween Sleep Troubles with Ask Doctor G

Reply

19 Tina @ Life Without Pink June 28, 2012 at 8:31 pm

Awe that’s so sweet! I am hoping my sister has a girl one day…then I can spoil her and be the cool Aunt!
Tina @ Life Without Pink´s last [type] ..How To Carve A T-Rex Watermelon

Reply

20 Nolie June 25, 2012 at 10:11 pm

I tell everyone I was made to be a mom of boys. I don’t do hair, make up or play dress up. When we tried for little brother I said give me a girl. He didn’t and I am perfectly fine with that. I am a proud mom of boys and wouldn’t change it for the world.
Nolie´s last [type] ..Happy 5th Birthday Big Brother

Reply

21 Tina @ Life Without Pink June 28, 2012 at 8:31 pm

Me too!
Tina @ Life Without Pink´s last [type] ..How To Carve A T-Rex Watermelon

Reply

22 Marie June 25, 2012 at 11:30 pm

Love your honesty!! I don’t envy moms with daughters because I enjoy having sons. Yes, there are days where I really could do without the fart jokes but I wouldn’t have it any other way.

Reply

23 Tina @ Life Without Pink June 28, 2012 at 8:32 pm

Haha…today was one of those crazy days w/two boys home all day jumping, wrestling, throwing things, etc. They are good just a bit loud sometimes!
Tina @ Life Without Pink´s last [type] ..How To Carve A T-Rex Watermelon

Reply

24 Lisa June 25, 2012 at 11:44 pm

We have 4 boys and my husband is more than done. With my first, I was fine with a boy. The second, I was disappointed he wasn’t a girl but after multiple miscarriages, I was just happy he “stuck”. Third was supposed to be the last and I was upset he turned out to be a boy. With the fourth, at my ultrasound, she originally said girl and I was sooo happy. 5 minutes later “oops, it’s really a boy.” Utter devastation. I was still hoping maybe she’d been right the first time until he was born. I adore him and he’s my sweetest baby ever. Wouldn ‘t trade him for anything, I just wish he’d come with a sister. My husband also really wanted a daughter, but seems to be handling it a lot better than I am. Probably because I’m not only missing having a girl, I’m also not really ready to be done but dh would have been happy with just 1 kid.

Reply

25 Tina @ Life Without Pink June 28, 2012 at 8:33 pm

Oh that must be so hard though when they tell you “its a girl”. Happened to my friend too. I would probably have another but I know we are done. I would just love to see what our little “girl” would look like :)
Tina @ Life Without Pink´s last [type] ..How To Carve A T-Rex Watermelon

Reply

26 Karla June 26, 2012 at 2:38 am

I’ll never forget my feelings of extreme devastation when we found out that we were not expecting a girl. We knew a 3rd child would complete our family regardless of sex. We are overjoyed and extremely blessed with 3 healthy, beautiful sons…and I wouldn’t ever change being a boy-Mom! Tonight as I was buckling them into their booster seats after t-ball I thought to myself that I am really good at raising boys. Once I allowed myself to grieve for the daughter that would not be born and raised of our family, then I could celebrate the miracle who would be our baby boy. My LDPP nurses even commented that finding out ahead of time greatly reduced the risk of developing post-pardum depression.

Reply

27 Tina @ Life Without Pink June 28, 2012 at 8:36 pm

Oh never thought about it that way. I never found out the sex w/both my kids. I knew we would probably only have 2 kids. The last time around, I wanted to find out but my hubby didn’t. Then I figured I would wait. Since I was slightly hoping for a daughter, I thought if I wanted and it was a boy at that moment {in labor} it wouldn’t matter and I wouldn’t have time to think…which is how it turned out. I remember just thinking how crazy it was that my two boys looked completely different!
Tina @ Life Without Pink´s last [type] ..How To Carve A T-Rex Watermelon

Reply

28 Ritty June 26, 2012 at 8:08 am

I have a girl that I love so very much. But I am praying for my next pregnacy to be twin boys.My sister have boys and the fun they have with their kids is so different from what I have with my Princess. I want to share in the experience but this time, a double portion of it

Reply

29 Tina @ Life Without Pink June 28, 2012 at 8:37 pm

Awe, never thought about how “girl moms” might secretly being hoping for a boy. Great follow up post, haha.
Tina @ Life Without Pink´s last [type] ..How To Carve A T-Rex Watermelon

Reply

30 Tina @ Life Without Pink June 28, 2012 at 8:38 pm

Awe, never thought about how “girl moms” might secretly be hoping for a boy. Great follow up post, haha.
Tina @ Life Without Pink´s last [type] ..How To Carve A T-Rex Watermelon

Reply

31 Sarah Hughes June 26, 2012 at 2:23 pm

I was certain my first was a girl, I was destined for pink and ribbons and bows. Derek, my first child, is certainly not a girl and he is “all boy” as some say. He runs, jumps, never sits still, loves superheroes, makes potty jokes and once I had him I wanted another boy!!!! I was sure my second was going to be a boy, I didn’t ache for ribbons and bows anymore. I wanted a baseball buddy and best friend for Derek. Hayley, my second, is “all girl”!! I love them both for everything they are but when I only had Derek, I was not jealous of anything but the wardrobe choices!!!

Reply

32 Tina @ Life Without Pink June 28, 2012 at 8:39 pm

That’s how I feel…it’s the clothes that gets me! I always tell them that they have a best friend for life and it’s really cool watching them play. They are really close and I just hope it remains that way.
Tina @ Life Without Pink´s last [type] ..How To Carve A T-Rex Watermelon

Reply

33 Jacki June 28, 2012 at 11:56 am

I was never jealous of mom’s with daughter, but it was a long time before I got over the feeling of wanting a daughter. Now that I am a step-mom to a 12 year-old girl, I understand that I was meant to be a boymom. Which shouldn’t have shocked me so much given I was always “one of the guys” growing up. My son and I have a great relationship, and I don’t see that changing even as he ages. He has said, when being teased about being a momma’s boy, that he is a momma’s boy and intends to stay that way until he is at least 30.
Jacki´s last [type] ..Keep It Real – How Do Photoshopped Images Impact You?

Reply

34 Tina @ Life Without Pink June 28, 2012 at 8:40 pm

That’s how I felt…not jealous just wanted a daughter but after my second {when I knew I was done} it went away. I love what your son said!
Tina @ Life Without Pink´s last [type] ..How To Carve A T-Rex Watermelon

Reply

35 Jessica June 28, 2012 at 7:21 pm

Thank you for such a great site. I always dreamed of having a little girl…when I was younger my “babies” were always girls. As a teenager I worked at a kids retail store and even hoarded girl clothes away for that day I would finally have my little girl. After my first son was born I couldn’t wait to have another baby because I knew that my next one would be a girl and would make my family complete (we only wanted 2 as well). As soon as I got pregnant EVERYONE was saying IT’S A GIRL! But I knew deep down that I had a little boy growing inside. I found out the sex of both my kids because I didn’t want to be disappointed when they were born. It gave me time to adjust to the fact that there wasn’t going to be pink or tutus or hair accessories or Barbies. But as my youngest turns 2, I am still feeling sad inside, especially since my best friend gave birth to her second….a girl, in March. I was over joyed but I was also terribly sad. I know that I will never have that bond that I was wishing for all my life.

As I say that and write this, I can only be reminded of what I do have. I have two very smart, happy, little guys who I love with all my heart. Would I change them? Never. I have a great relationship with my mother-in-law. Sometimes I think she likes me more then my husband. I can only hope that one day I have that relationship with my daughters-in-law one day. I will do everything in my power to keep my kids close, while giving them room to breath. I will cherish every moment I have with them…and I have to admit I love fishing and trucks and trains and dirt…everything that comes along with being a mom to boys. And my hubby knows…MANY girls weekends are a necessity throughout the year!!

I know that this lust for a girl will get smaller and smaller as the years go on. I am not about to sit by and watch my boys grow up with out me being a part of their lives.

Reply

36 Tina @ Life Without Pink June 28, 2012 at 8:44 pm

Wow I could have written this! However, I didn’t find out the sex w/my kids. I wanted to w/the second but decided not to. I didn’t want any chance of me feeling down during my pregnancy. When they told me “it’s a boy” for only one second I thought “Wow I’ll never have a daughter” but that quickly went away. Everyone told me they thought I was having a girl, but like you I knew deep down it was a boy. I agree, I just hope I’m a cool MIL and I want to have a strong, close relationship w/both my boys. I love spending time w/them and doing “boy” stuff. I really think there is something special about being a mom to all boys {and I’m not just saying that because I am one, lol}.
Tina @ Life Without Pink´s last [type] ..How To Carve A T-Rex Watermelon

Reply

37 Elaine A. June 29, 2012 at 2:56 pm

I have two boys and a girl and I was SO expecting when I got pregnant with my 3rd that it was going to be another boy (I have 3 older brothers myself!) but she IS all girl. My point is I would have been SO okay with another boy but when I would tell people I was having a girl they would look SO relieved. I just don’t get it. What the heck is wrong with all boys??! NOTHING!! I LOVE the relationship I have with my boys and I’m looking forward to having daughters-in-law (if it works out that way!).

Great POST! :)
Elaine A.´s last [type] ..My Husband

Reply

38 Caroline Rudd February 19, 2013 at 8:34 pm

I am a mother of two athletic and energetic boys ages 12 and 13. I feel blessed to be a boy mom, although, not at first! I always thought I would have 2 kids, 1 boy and 1 girl! When I found out my first was a boy, I simply thought the next would be a girl, especially since the pregnancy was so different! I even went shopping for little pink dresses!
When I found out my second was a boy I cried! My first thought was that I was going to grow old alone!
I now realize that could not be farther from the truth! I feel lucky to have that special bond that a mom can only have with a son!

Reply

39 Life Without Pink February 19, 2013 at 8:48 pm

I completely agree with you. I am super close with my boys and I only hope it stays that way. I always say, “I was made to be a mom of boys” :) Thanks for stopping by!

Reply

Leave a Comment

CommentLuv badge

Previous post:

Next post: